Skip to main content

AI in Design: Set Criteria Before You Approve an Output

Strategy

2 min read

by Rafael Machado

Colegas discutindo um trabalho em um tablet no escritório

Generative models do not produce the same result twice. That is why design judgment needs to become written criteria: what counts as good, what is unacceptable, and what changes the verdict.

Adam Elman, from the Nielsen Norman Group, makes this case in a June 2026 article on design critique in the AI era: The Core Skill of Design in the AI Era: Critique.

Why AI output requires explicit criteria

When the criteria appear only after you have seen the result, they tend to adjust to what is already there, and the review stops being a real test. Writing the criteria first protects the decision.

A three-step evaluation cycle

  • Define what “good” means before looking at the output, with approved and rejected examples.
  • Use automated evaluators (models that judge other outputs) only after calibrating them against human annotations.
  • Monitor regressions: whenever the model or prompt changes, run the same set of cases.

Elman summarizes the process in three verbs: judge, evaluate, and iterate. Each cycle should be recorded, so the next decision has a basis.

The limit for visual interfaces

The author himself acknowledges that the method is not yet clear for visual interfaces, where criteria depend on hierarchy, context, and intent. Judging a screen with an automated evaluator is harder than judging text or code.

What to do in practice

  • Write a criteria document for each screen or flow, with examples.
  • Keep human review before approval, even with an automated evaluator running.
  • Record why each output was accepted or rejected.

Frequently asked questions

Can design evaluation be automated?

In part. Objective checks, such as contrast, touch target size, and alt text, can be automated. Judgments about hierarchy and intent still require human review.

Why define criteria before seeing the output?

Because without written criteria beforehand, the evaluation becomes an opinion about the result already in front of you, not a test against a standard.

Webflow Premium Partner

Let’s bring your big idea to life.